If you're following along with the podcast episodes I've shared about Overtures to the 2025 General Assembly, you'll know that for the most part, I've focused on helping folks understand the purpose of the Overture, potential pros and cons, and a general sense of the ongoing conversation. I've had some opinions along the way, too.
But there's one Overture that I haven't seen discussed with much depth, and it's the one I'm most concerned about this year. Overture 31 deals with administrative suspension of an officer (especially a pastor) during trial.
You can download the full text of the Overture here if you want to read it.
This Overture was a last minute addition, submitted just a few days before the cutoff for sending Overtures to amend the Book of Church order to the 2025 General Assembly. At first glance, it may sound like a common-sense change and perhaps that's why it hasn't gotten much attention.
Background on Administrative Suspension
In order to explain my concerns, I’m going to have to get into a bit of Book of Church Order background information.
First, let’s talk about how censures work in PCA trials. The Book of Church Order is very clear that censures can only be given in response to either a confession of guilt or a finding of guilt in a trial. For example, if you remember from Jeanie’s story - our first storyteller on the Stories from the Presbyterian Pew podcast - her church was wrong to tell her that she wasn’t allowed to take communion for six months without any trial or confession.
However, there are provisions for an officer to be temporarily removed from his official duties during the process of the trial. BCO 31-10 says …
When a member of a church court is under process, all his official functions may be suspended at the court’s discretion; but this shall never be done in the way of censure, and this requires a two-thirds (2/3) majority.
The book of church order is clear that this administrative suspension isn’t a censure. But the challenge is that it’s still a subjective decision.
Enacting an administrative suspension requires a ⅔ vote of the court. That means that some judgment must be made by the court about the severity of the accusations made against the accused and/or the damage that could possibly be done if he was allowed to continue to perform the duties of his office while on trial. So while it isn’t a censure, it also isn’t an objective, automatic procedure.
In other professions such as medicine, mental healthcare, or law enforcement, an ethics complaint might result in an automatic suspension while the investigation is ongoing. I've watched enough Law & Order to know that when an officer discharges his weapon, he is put on administrative leave pending an investigation. This isn't a presumption of guilt. Because it is a procedural protocol, it can be truly neutral and without judgement.
Personally, I think the PCA would do well to have such a policy. For example, if a judicial commission finds a strong presumption of guilt on charges related to harming those under the care of an officer, then the officer would be automatically suspended from office pending the investigation. (Note: That isn't the case at the moment and that isn't under consideration in this Overture or any other this year, this is just my tangential opinion.)
Background on Presbytery Judicial Commissions
Next let me give you some background information about judicial commissions. BCO 15-3 says in part,
Presbytery as a whole may hear a case … or it may of its own motion commit such a case to a commission. …The judgment of the commission shall be the decision of the Presbytery, and the statement of the case and judgment printed in its minutes.
Up until 2023, that final sentence read, “If Presbytery approves, the judgment of the commission shall be final and shall be entered on the minutes of Presbytery as the action. If Presbytery disapproves, it shall hear the case as a whole, or appoint a new commission to hear the case again.”
In other words, it used to be that case that if a Presbytery elected a commission to try a case, the decision of that commission then had to be approved by the Presbytery. Now, the decision of a commission is the decision of the Presbytery, and no vote of approval is needed.
The rational of the Overture that led to this change pointed out that if a Presbytery wishes to have final approval of the results of a case, they can appoint a judicial committee rather than a judicial commission.
If you know a bit about Robert’s Rules of Order (or if you've taken our Presbyterian Church Government 101 course), you’ll know that a committee is tasked with work that it completes and reports on to the main body for approval, while a commission is tasked with work that it is empowered to fully complete. This 2023 change essentially brought Presbytery judicial commissions into accord with all other commissions, giving them the power to fully complete their work without approval needed from the full Presbytery.
That brings us all the way back to the subject of Overture 31.
The Substance of Overture 31
Overture 31 argues that because the administrative suspension of a teaching elder puts a great burden on a church the ⅔ vote necessary for an administrative suspension is a vote that should take place in the full Presbytery, not just in the judicial commission, even if the judicial commission has been tasked with handling every other aspect of the trial.
Objections to Overture 31
Here are a few problems that stand out to me with this change proposed in Overture 31.
Protection of the Sheep is Primary
The rationale of this Overture discussed only the hardship that may be experienced by the church and the teaching elder during an administrative suspension, not the hardships that may potentially be experienced by anyone who has been harmed by the teaching elder if he is not administratively suspended after a judicial commission has found a strong presumption of guilt.
I don't believe that every Overture has to examine every potential outcome of its proposed change in order to be a worthy Overture. In fact, I value simplicity and brevity in the Whereas or Rational of an Overture. However, in this case, it is worth noting that the focus is on the potential for logistical and financial hardships rather than on the potential for ongoing spiritual harm.
One common tactic of abusive pastors is to use their platform to shape and drive the narrative about the charges and process against them, and even shame church members directly yet covertly from the pulpit. An Overture that discusses administrative suspension of a pastor certainly needs to have in view the situations where the allegations relate to abuse of the flock. More on that in a moment.
Can We Trust Our Commissions?
The rational for Overture 31 discusses the potential that a very small number of people could be tasked with making such a weighty decision.
But remember that a judicial commission is normally tasked with:
- investigating a charge
- ruling whether or not there is a strong presumption of guilt
- drawing up an indictment with charges and specifications
- appointing a prosecutor
- vetting witnesses
- citing witnesses to testify
- holding a trial
- deciding a verdict
- deciding on a censure
- handling potential appeals
All without needing approval by a vote of the full Presbytery.
Why would a Presbytery be willing to trust a commission with a final verdict and censure, but not with a temporary, administrative suspension? If there is potential for corruption and injustice by tasking a small group of men with an important decision, certainly the greater danger is the final outcome of the trial, not the temporary administrative suspension.
And certainly men - including other teaching elders - who have been appointed or elected to a commission are well aware of the weightiness of suspending a man, especially a pastor, from his office as they would be of the weightiness of the full task before them.
Presbytery as Pastors' Union?
A while back, I watched a conversation with Ryan Biese and Matt Fender discussing a case colloquially referred to as the Jonesborough 7. In that interview, Mr. Fender referenced a concern that Presbyteries could become a "pastors' union".
I think there can be a tendency sometimes for it to be just that, for Presbyteries, guys in Presbyteries to look out for each other in in a sense that, gosh after all you know, these other Teaching Elders, these are my brothers, this is their job. You know, if you take any action against them, you know, the guy might lose his job. That's bad; it's his career, you know. And you Ruling Elder guys, you just don't really understand because you know for you this is just a hobby.
Overture 7, though not a subject of discussion in this article, cites the concerns raised about the ability of Presbyteries to hold pastors accountable:
Over the last several years far too many ministerial ethics and doctrinal scandals have undermined the work of the Church. As Presbyteries have sought to address these scandals critics of their efforts have arisen from both inside and outside the church. One thing that all these critics seem to have in common is their concern that Presbyteries are incapable of or unwilling to sanction their own.
The evidence supporting these claims is uneven, however, there is no doubt that there is a public perception that Presbyteries are networks of ‘good ole boys’ who protect their own from appropriate accountability, a perception that continues to damage the credibility of the Church.
Because of the nature of the two classes of elders - teaching elders and ruling elders - Presbyteries almost always have a higher percentage (sometimes a far higher percentage) of Teaching Elders than Ruling Elders. This is primarily because participation in Presbytery is a part of the job of a Teaching Elder whereas a Ruling Elder may need to take time off from his fulltime job in order to attend or participate.
In addition, in Presbyteries whose boundaries contain a seminary, Christian college, or a large parachurch organization that employs men ordained in the PCA, not only the percentage of teaching elders in Presbytery but also the likelihood that a Presbyter may have a fiduciary interest in the outcome of a trial of a fellow teaching elder increases.
A commission can be a carefully selected body of men, a balance of ruling and teaching elders, chosen to ensure that they do not have a conflict of interest due to their employment.
A Pre-Trial Trial?
Since our administrative censures are not currently objective but do require a judgement call, it's important to consider how a judicial commission that has already heard testimony during the investigation could convince the full Presbytery - which has not heard any of the testimony - that the administrative suspension should be put in place. Is this not requiring the commission to at least to some extent begin to try the case in open Presbytery before the trial even begins?
In the same interview mentioned above, Matt Fender referenced his recent work as a prosecutor in a trial against a pastor in our Presbytery for spiritual abuse. In speaking to him after the conclusion of the trial (in which the pastor was found guilty, indefinitely suspended, and eventually deposed) Mr. Fender described the job of a prosecutor in a case of abuse as "building a mosaic."
No one piece of evidence is the silver bullet, so to speak (nor should it be, as a proper assessment of abuse is about a pattern of behavior over time, not just one disturbing event). So it is the job of the prosecutor to carefully put all the pieces together to give a full picture of the character of the accused. How can a judicial commission piece together enough of a mosaic before a trial to convey the need for administrative suspension?
Again, as I mentioned above, I believe that the most ethical practice would be for administrative suspension to be a required measure in cases where officers are accused of harming the sheep and an investigation has found a strong presumption of guilt. This would make it an objective, procedural and truly neutral administrative suspension, rather than requiring some form of judgement from either the Presbytery or the commission.
A Relevant, Recent Example
I want to give an illustration of a case where this change would be very relevant. In the recent trial of Burk Parsons, the Minister and His Work Committee of the Central Florida Presbytery found a strong presumption of guilt. The Presbytery appointed a judicial commission and the prosecutor conducted further investigation. The prosecutor drew up charges and the commission voted to administratively suspended Parsons from office during the trial.
The trial was held in closed session for the protection of the witnesses and their testimony. The only people allowed to be present for the trial were the judicial commission, the prosecutor, Parsons himself, his defense counsel, and any individual witness who was testifying.
How might the vulnerability of the witnesses be protected if the judicial commission had to argue before the entire Presbytery to vote for an administrative suspension? How could a Presbytery vote knowledgably on an administrative suspension without the prosecutor revealing key aspect of the case and potentially opening the commissioners up to the charge of bias and prejudice as they hear details of the case outside of trial?
As I said before, I am in favor of an objective, automatic administrative suspension. But barring that possibility, the decision ought to be left with the judicial commission who is already handling the investigation, trial, verdict, and censure.
I haven't made such a direct statement about any other Overture this year, but I am praying that the General Assembly would vote down Overture 31.

Could you comment on how the functions of investigation have recently been separated from judicial process at the Presbytery level and how this serves the judicial procedures for the inherent interest of justice? Also, wondering if administrative suspension translates into no pay for a pastor and if this would effectively mean financial 'starvation' for a person who ought to still be considered innocent until proven guilty.
Hi, Carol. I’m afraid I don’t know what you’re referring to when you talk about investigations recently separated from judicial process at the Presbytery level. In general, administrative suspension does not involve loss of pay for pastors. It may be an increased financial burden on the congregation if they need to hire pulpit supply while also paying their pastor’s salary.
It’s also important to note that “innocent until proven guilty” does not mean that there are no impositions put in place. A person in our civil judicial system may be “innocent until proven guilty” and yet held in custody awaiting trial. If there is reason to believe that it is necessary, administratively suspending an officer from his duties while awaiting trial can be an important safeguard for the peace and purity of the church.