2025 PCA General Assembly Overtures

A total of 49 Overtures (50 originally, but one has since been withdrawn) have been submitted to the 2025 (52nd) General Assembly. This page will provide general information on Overtures and the issues they address.

Helpful Reading:

Links to 2025 Overtures

You can find all of the 2025 Overtures here. The title of each Overture is hyperlinked so that you can view or download a PDF of the actual Overture.

Types of Overtures

For the purposes of tracking and discussion, Presbyterian Pew has divided the 2025 Overtures into seven categories. These aren't denomination-assigned categories, but an editorial decision based on the type and topic of the Overtures.

Presbytery Boundaries

Overtures 2, 17, 20, 21, 28, 36, 45, and 46 contain requests to change the boundaries of various Presbyteries. These proposed changes all come from Presbyteries involved in the request and do not appear to be controversial. (Note: Overture 21 was withdrawn by the Presbytery.)

Studies, Study Committees, and Pastoral Letters

Christian Nationalism

These Overtures relate to the ongoing debate, especially in Reformed circles, about the definition of Christian Nationalism and related terms and how they compare to Scripture.

Overtures 3, 4, and 47 ask the General Assembly to form a study committee on Christian Nationalism. The language for the formation of the committee varies slightly between these three Overtures. The budget for the Ad Interim Committee would be about $10k per year and the three Presbyteries submitting these Overtures have already pledged a combined total of $8,500 of that amount.

Overture 48 requests an Ad Interim Committee to write a pastoral letter on "Christian Citizenship and Church-State Relations". While this Overture has been presented as a cheaper and simpler alternative to a study committee on Christian Nationalism, its focus is narrower than the proposed study committees.

Other Studies and Study Committees

Overture 11 requests the sessions and Presbyteries of the PCA to consider and study the risks and benefits of incorporating bitcoin into their balance sheets and, as they are able, to share the results of their research into this matter with the denomination more broadly.

Overture 26 asks the General Assembly to form a Study Committee to revise the Directory for Worship so that it can become fully constitutionally binding.

Overture 27 proposed a Study Committee to solicit input from sessions and Presbyteries about ways the Permanent Committees and Agencies of the General Assembly can streamline or optimize spending and use of resources.

Overture 49 requests the General Assembly to form a Study Committee on AI and specifically its use or application in the church or Christian vocation.

Overture 50 is neither a request for a study nor a pastoral letter, but rather a self-contained encouragement for discernment and compassion in the way we interact with immigrants.

The Directory for Worship

The first two sections of the Book of Church Order - the Form of Government and the Rules of Discipline - are constitutionally binding. The third section - the Directory for Worship - is only partially constitutionally binding (specifically, sections that have to do with the sacraments and marriage). There has been a move recently to make more or all of the Directory for Worship constitutionally binding.

As mentioned above, Overture 26 request the General Assembly to form a Study Committee to revise the entire Directory of Worship for full constitutional status. Two other Overtures propose to make immediate changes in this direction.

Overture 5 seeks to grant full constitutional status to Chapters 60-63 of the Book of Church Order. These chapters cover the following topics:

  • The Visitation of the Sick
  • The Burial of the Dead
  • Days of Fasting and Thanksgiving
  • Christian Life in the Home

Overture 12 proposes to amend BCO 58-5 to specify that only officers of the church may distribute the Lord's Supper. The Book of Church Order already restricts the administration of the Lord's Supper to Teaching Elders only. This Overture seeks to constitutionalize who may pass out the elements once the Teaching Elder has administered them.

Officers and Ordination

Quite a number of Overtures have been proposed related to the ordination of officers in the church. Here's a summary.

Overture 6 seeks to adjust the requirement that applicants who wish to come under care of Presbytery must submit that application more than a month in advance of the Presbytery meeting by allowing Presbyteries to set their own deadline.

Overture 8 suggests that just as teaching elders must state (and the Presbytery must report) their stated difference with the Westminster Confession before ordination, ruling elders and deacons must do the same and their exceptions be recorded in the minutes of the session.

Overture 10 deals with the office of Assistant Pastor. This office is a bit of an anomaly in the PCA. Preliminary Principal 6 states that congregations have the right to vote on anyone who will have authority over them. Unlike Solo, Senior, or Associate Pastors, Assistant Pastors are chosen not by the congregation, but by the session. While Assistant Pastors do not have a vote on the session (as they have not been elected by the congregation to govern them) they do have a vote at Presbytery and General Assembly. This Overture seeks to limit the duration of an Assistant Pastor's call.

Overture 24 deals with a portion of the BCO 24-1 that was just added within the last couple of years. Although it doesn't explicitly say so, it was adopted in response to concerns about how a candidate for office describes his struggle with same-sex attraction. The original amendment (the text as it currently stands) includes this sentence:

"[T]he Session may render a decision on Christian experience at any point in the process, and based on that decision, may judge him ineligible for that election."

This amendment would change that sentence to allow for this judgement of ineligibility to apply not only to candidates standing for election for the first time, but also to candidates who have previously been elected to office.

"[T]he Session may render a decision on Christian experience at any point in the process, and based on that decision, may judge the nominee, whether previously ordained or not, ineligible for that election."

Overture 25 seeks to add a class of associate membership for honorably retired teaching elders. Teaching elders are members of Presbyteries and not members of local churches. Normally if a teaching elder moves to work in another Presbytery, his membership would be transferred to a new Presbytery after they new Presbytery has approved his call and the sending Presbytery has approved his release.

However an honorably retired teaching elder wouldn't ordinarily be taking a call and therefore wouldn't have a mechanism for transferring Presbyteries even if he moved to a different location. The associate membership proposed in this Overture would enable him to maintain membership in the Presbytery in which he was honorably retired while being assigned to the care of a local church for shepherding.

Overture 30 relates to the call of a teaching elder who is serving out of bounds in a "needful work". While there are clear guidelines about the interactions between a local church and a Presbytery when a church calls a teaching elder (pastor), the interactions between Presbytery and another organization (even including Committees and Agencies of the PCA) in the call and ordination of a teaching elder are less clear. Further, some of the vows of ordination for a teaching elder to not apply to men taking a call somewhere other than a local church.

Overture 34 requests the General Assembly to require each Presbytery Directory to include a listing of the ordained ruling elder and deacons from each church as well as who performs the functions of a deaconate if there are no ordained deacons.

Voting, Membership Vows, and Children's Membership

Overture 13 seeks to reconcile two portions of the Book of church order to make the wording more uniform. In the chapter on the election of officers, BCO 24-3 says

"All communing members in good and regular standing, but no others, are entitled to vote in the election of church officers ..."

In the next chapter about congregational meetings, BCO 25-1 says,

"The congregation consists of all the communing members of a particular church, and they only are entitled to vote."

The Overture proposes to amend BCO 25-1 to say

"The congregation consists of all the communing members of a particular church, and only members in good and regular standing are entitled to vote."

Overture 19 proposes to amend the vows of church membership as outlined in BCO 57-5 by slightly changing the wording of the current second and fifth vows and adding a new first vow (creating a total of six):

"Do you agree that you are made in the image of God, designed by God to glorify God and enjoy Him forever?"

Recently, discussion has arisen about admitting young (even very young) children to full communicate membership and the Lord's Supper and whether these young members are fully capable of voting for church officers. Two Overtures have been proposed related to these concerns.

Overture 22 seeks to allow congregations to set a minimum age for voting in officer elections by adding a sentence to BCO 25-1. (This Overture includes a 19-page rationale!)

"A congregation may establish a rule setting a minimum voting age (regular standing), but it must be adopted by a two-thirds (2/3) majority at a congregational meeting that is called with at least 30 days' notice."

Overture 33 proposes to add clarification about the process of admitting a young person to church membership by including this sentence in BCO 57-2, a paragraph which speaks about examining young people for membership in the church.

The examination shall include an evaluation of the young person’s credible profession of faith, the young person’s understanding of the meaning of the Lord’s Supper, and the young person’s understanding of the questions in BCO 57-5.

Permanent Committees and Agencies

There are a number of Overtures related to various aspects of the General Assembly's Permanent Committees and Agencies.

Overture 9 seeks to limit the voting members of the Administrative Committee to only those who have been elected by the Assembly "at large". This diagram will give you a quick overview of the current formation of the Committee. For more detail, see the lesson on the Administrative Committee in our Presbyterian General Assembly 101 course.

Currently, 9 of the 20 voting members of the Administrative Committee are representatives chosen from among the membership of the 9 Program Committees and Agencies. This Overture would make those representatives advisory members, not voting members.

Overture 18 asks the General Assembly to require RUF (Reformed University Fellowship - the PCA's Campus Ministry program) to update their "Campus Ministry Manual" for General Assembly Approval

Overture 28 suggests that the General Assembly should "Demand Mission to North America (MNA) to Apologize and Terminate Personnel." A few months ago, an organization under the umbrella of MNA published a webpage with links to third party organizations that provide legal advice to undocumented immigrants. There was an outcry about this page. It was taken down and apology issued. This Overture seeks further punitive action.

Overture 35 is a request that the Administrative Committee study and report on locations for General Assembly. There have been challenges recently when General Assembly is held in cities that are not hubs for major airline or that lack enough hotel and restaurant options to make attending as smooth as possible.

Overture 41 requests that the Administrative Committee collect and report data on each congregation's meeting times on the Church Directory map on the Administrative Committee website.

Overture 42 requests the General Assembly to direct the Stated Clerk not to collect data about the age and ethnicity of members of PCA congregations. Apparently on the form that the Administrative Committee sends out each year to collect data about the number of communicant and non-communicant members, there was a note that beginning in 2026, they will also be collecting data about age and ethnicity of church members. This Overture would require the Stated Clerk not to request that data.

Overture 43 is closely related to Overture 42 in that it suggests an amendment to Rules of Assembly Operation (RAO) 4-11. Here is the paragraph in question as it currently reads, with the suggested amended language added in bold.

"The Administrative Committee shall annually provide and publish guidelines for the Partnership Share Giving Program of the PCA, including the Ministry Ask. These guidelines shall include statistical information expressed both in per capita giving terms and in proportional (percentage) giving terms to demonstrate the giving necessary to attain full funding for budgets of the General Assembly Committees and Agencies. Such statistical information shall not include data pertaining to age or ethnicity."

Overture 44 seeks to transition byFaith, the denominational digital publication, into a press-release-based publication and limit what they publish to news as released by the Presbyteries, eliminating op-ed or personal interest pieces.

Judicial Cases

All of the Overtures in this category relate to the procedures in a church court trial.

Elevating a Censure

Recent PCA court cases have raised a question about the proper procedure to follow when elevating a censure of indefinite suspension to either excommunication or deposition. In other words, if, following a confession or trial, someone is censured with indefinite suspension from the sacraments or indefinite suspension from their office, what should be done when, after an extended period of time, there is no evidence of repentance. Three Overtures seek to provide answers to that question in various ways.

Overture 32 seeks to provide a specific process by adding an extra paragraph to BCO 36. The solution this Overture proposes is a hearing, which would be a middle ground between a mere vote with no opportunity for the accused to provide evidence in his defense or a full trial, which could be time-consuming and redundant.

Overture 38 also seeks to address the question of how to elevate a censure of indefinite suspension to excommunication or deposition, but this Overture proposes requiring a completely new trial. It also proposes this change by seeking to amend BCO 30-4 which requires a “gross sin or heresy”.

Overture 39 proposes another way to handle the elevation of a censure of indefinite suspension from office to deposition by adding an additional paragraph to BCO 34-8 which addresses restoring a teaching elder who has been indefinitely suspended and an additional section to BCO 33 regarding ruling elders to parallel the wording about teaching elders in 34-8. This Overture does not address the process of elevating a suspension from the sacraments to excommunication.

Other Judicial Overtures

Overture 1 seeks to address situations in which an individual might bring charges against someone and what latitude the court should have in a given situation. Currently, church courts are required to hold a trial when an individual brings charges. This Overture proposes to provide some room for discretion on the part of the court before beginning a formal trial.

Overture 7 addresses two different issues by making two amendments to the same paragraph of the Book of Church Order. First, it adds an allowance for including ruling or teaching elders from other Presbyteries as advisory (non-voting) members of a judicial commission. It also changes the threshold for asking the Standing Judicial Commission to take original jurisdiction over a case from two Presbyteries to five Presbyteries and requires that those Presbyteries be able to cite the exact portion of the Book of Church Order that was not followed.

Overture 14 proposes to allow more flexibility in who must participate in the steps of a trial such as presenting the accused with the charges and hearing his plea. Currently the BCO requires this to be done by the “court” but the Overture proposes to allow it to be handled by the Moderator or his designee to limit the number of multi-person meetings that need to be scheduled.

Overture 15 seeks to add specific wording to be used when administering the censure of definite suspension. The Book of Church Order currently gives a clear script for the administration of other censures, but not this one.

Overture 16 proposes to add one single word (plus a slash) to the Book of Church Order. The impact of this small change, however, would be to make it clear that someone who is being suspended from office isn’t necessarily suspended from the sacraments. The new wording would be “and/or” instead of “and”.

Overture 23 recognizes the fact that often in small churches, the session may not have enough members to make up a reasonably-sized judicial commission, including a moderator, a prosecutor, potentially an advocate for the accused person, and enough men left to be judges on the trial. This Overture proposes to allow other members of the Presbytery to serve as supplemental judges in a session trial.

Overture 29 deals with minority decisions of the Standing Judicial Commission - the PCA’s highest court. Althought this has never yet happened in the history of the PCA, if there were to be a minority opinion on an SJC case, the General Assembly would need to vote on the matter. This Overture amends how this vote would be handled and also the means of distributing the information to the necessary parties.\

Overture 31 relates to the administrative suspension of someone facing trial. Censures (such as suspension from office or suspension from the sacraments) can only be applied after a guilty verdict through confession or a trial. However there are times where it may be necessary to temporarily suspend someone while a trial is ongoing depending on the severity of the accusations against them. This Overture would require a ⅔ vote of an entire Presbytery, not just a ⅔ vote of the judicial commission handling the case in order to enact such a suspension.

Overture 37 seeks to amend the BCO to allow ruling elders to moderate a judicial commission of the session. Currently, BCO 12-3 says that when a church is without a pastor, a teaching elder from another church in the Presbytery must moderate a judicial commission. The amendment would leave this as an option while also allowing the session to elect one of the ruling elders to serve as moderator.

Overture 40 requires that all parts of a trial, including things such as the opening statement and questions from the court, be recorded in the transcript of the trial, not just the witness testimony, excluding the private deliberation of the judges.

Overtures Referred to Committees

The Overtures Committee is responsible for most but not all Overtures. Committees that have responsibility for an Overture will present their recommendations for that Overture on the Floor of the General Assembly during that Committee's report.

Sometimes Overtures are referred to multiple committees. Only one committee will be responsible to present its recommendations on the floor of General Assembly but the other committees are asked for their advice on Overtures that impact or relate to their work.

Here are the committees to which the 2025 Overtures have been assigned or referred for advice.

Mission to North America (MNA)

Mission to North America is the domestic missions branch of the PCA. It is also the agency that manages Presbytery boundaries. All Overtures related to Presbytery boundary changes are the responsibility of MNA.

7 Overtures - 2, 17, 20, (21 now withdrawn), 28, 36, 45, and 46 - have been referred to MNA for recommendationd.

Overtures Committee

The Overtures Committee is a temporary Committee made up of Commissioners to the General Assembly. They are tasked with amending Overtures if necessary and providing recommendations about those Overtures on the floor of General Assembly.

37 Overtures - 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 19, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 37, 38, 39, 40, 43, 47, 48, 49, and 50 - have been referred to the Overtures Committee for recommendations.

Committee on Constitutional Business (CCB)

Any Overture that proposes changes to the Constitution of the PCA (including the Book of Church Order and Rules of Assembly Operations) will be referred to the Committee on Constitutional Business for advice. The CCB does not advise on the merits of an Overture or whether it should be passed, but only whether the Overture is in conflict with some other portion of the Constitution.

This Committee reports its advice before the Overtures Committee meets to discuss the Overtures.

The Committee on Constitutional Business was asked to advise on Overtures 1, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10,  12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 19, 22, 23, 24, 25, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 37, 38, 39, 40, and 43  (all Overtures referred to the Overtures Committee).

Administrative Committee (AC)

The Administrative Committee of the PCA manages various administrative and organizational tasks within the PCA. The Stated Clerk of the PCA is the head of the Administrative Committee. Like the CCB, the AC may be asked to give advice on Overtures that are ultimately the responsibility of the Overtures Committee. This advice may include input on the logistical or financial aspects of an Overture such as the formation of a Study Committee.

The Administrative Committee also reports its advice before the Overtures Committee meets to discuss the Overtures.

Overtures 3, 4, 9, 11, 26, 27, 30, 43, 47, 48, and 49 were referred to the Administrative Committee for advice.

4 Overtures - 35, 41, 42, and 44 - were referred to the Administrative Committee for their recommendation (this means that the Administrative Committee - not the Overtures Committee - will be responsible to make a recommendation on these Overtures in their report to General Assembly).

Other Committees and Agencies

A handful of 2024 Overtures involve a number of other Committees and Agencies and have been referred to them for advice as well.

Overtures 9, 11, 27, 30, and 49 were referred to a wide range of other Committees for advice.

1 Overture - 18 - was referred to RUF their recommendation.

Resources on 2025 Overtures

Several individuals and groups in the PCA put together a collection of views or their thoughts on Overtures preceding each General Assembly. These documents and their sources are included below in full and will be quoted in discussions of specific Overture topics.

These documents are all publicly available and/or shared with permission from the authors. Please see each author's comments and disclaimers about his own commentary.

The Presbyterian Pew shares these documents for informational purposes only. Posting of these documents should not be considered endorsement by Presbyterian Pew of any of the views or opinions they contain.

  • Pastor Scott Edburg and Pastor Jared Nelson Resource (Google Doc link)
  • Ruling Elder Howie Donahoe Summary Chart and Comments on Overtures (PDF download)
  • Dr. David Coffin Comments on Overtures (PDF download)
  • Pastor Fred Greco Comments on Overtures (PDF download)
  • Presbycast Podcasts on 2025 Overtures (Part 1, Part 2)
  • Polity Matters Podcast on Overtures (Part 1, more coming soon)
  • Stories from the Presbyterian Pew Podcasts on Overtures (coming soon)

What questions do you have about the Overtures to the 2025 PCA General Assembly?

Want to ask more questions about these Overtures and how they will be handled in General Assembly? Join our free Facebook Group Presbyterian Pew Guide to the 2025 PCA General Assembly.

About the author 

Lynna Sutherland

Lynna has been in the PCA since 1982. Four generations of her family have participated in PCA church planting. Lynna has been around long enough to see the good, the bad, and the ugly and her particular calling is to equip the people in the pew to understand their church government and to advocate for victims of abuse in the PCA.

  • This is so very helpful, Lynna! Thanks for taking the time to provide the synopsis of these overtures. You are appreciated!

  • {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
    >